Back to Blog
Coach Insights·November 18, 2026

The Evidence Exercise: how to get unstuck by counting what you have already survived

Tara Resnick and HatchPath founder Jordan Dunin on the sunk cost fallacy, doing things scared, and the five steps that turn your history into proof

The Evidence Exercise: how to get unstuck by counting what you have already survived
Tara Resnick

Tara Resnick

Solution-Focused Coach · Life & Career

View Profile

🎙️ Listen to the Full Episode

Jordan Dunin opened this summit with a story he has told before and will keep telling. In 2016 he broke his neck. He was told a great deal about what his life would look like afterward, and most of it was not encouraging. What got him out of that year was not motivation. It was a coach who asked him a better question than the one he was asking himself. He kept asking why me. She asked, what is the one thing you can still do. Tara Resnick is a solution-focused coach, and this session was that same move at scale. Not a pep talk. A better question, and a pen.

Why Waiting to Feel Ready Keeps You Stuck

Tara started with the thing almost everyone gets wrong. We believe we have to talk ourselves into getting unstuck, or talk ourselves into feeling confident. We wait for the day we feel ready. That day does not come, and the waiting itself deepens the stuck feeling.

Her reframe is plain and it holds up. Confidence is not something you summon before the hard thing. It is evidence you collect over time. You do the difficult thing, and the proof of having done it is what you get to keep. Which means the order most of us try to work in is backwards.

"Ready is a decision, it is not a feeling. You have to just do things scared." - Tara Resnick

She knows this as lived experience, not theory. At 30 she had a plan: married with kids by 35. Instead she stayed in the wrong relationship until she was 38, not because it was working, but because she was scared of starting over. She had bought the sunk cost fallacy whole. It is too late, I have invested so much time, I cannot start over. Her fear of wasting time is what wasted her time, and it cost her motherhood. She had been a solution-focused coach long before that chapter, which she offers as the point. None of us coach ourselves well. Even coaches need an outside voice most of the time.

The Sunk Cost Fallacy, and the Sunk Investment

The sunk cost fallacy is when you have put so much time into something, a career, a relationship, a city, a version of your life, that you stay in it because leaving feels like admitting the time was wasted. You tell yourself you have already come this far. That reasoning is what keeps most people stuck far longer than they should be.

Jordan offered a reframe that Tara immediately told him to trademark. What if it is not a sunk cost but a sunk investment. He built a clothing company, Joe and Co., before he got sick. It was not big, and they shut it down before HatchPath existed. For a while he filed it under wasted time and distraction. Then he noticed he had learned e-commerce, operations, and how to build something from nothing, and every bit of that knowledge went straight into the next thing.

The time is gone either way. You cannot take the choice back. What you can do is treat the choice as a catalyst, or a catapult, for what comes next. Almost nothing good in anyone's life arrived out of something good. It arrives out of something difficult, and the people who get to use it are the ones who let it evolve into something.

The Evidence Exercise

Tara then walked the room through the exercise she calls the Evidence Exercise. It takes a pen and paper, or the notes app on your phone, and about fifteen minutes. Pick one hard thing you have already come through. It could be twenty years ago or it could be yesterday. A relationship ending, a career setback, a major transition, a difficult decision, a time you had to advocate for yourself, a situation where you had to figure it out with no idea what came next. It does not have to be the hardest thing you have ever lived through. Choose something you are comfortable reflecting on today, because this is about gathering evidence, not reopening a wound.

  • Step 1: Write down the situation. What you were facing, and what made it difficult.
  • Step 2: Write down what you did. What decisions you made, what actions you took, what you did when things felt uncertain, and what helped you get through it.
  • Step 3: Write down the strengths you demonstrated. Were you resourceful, determined, adaptable, courageous. Did you advocate for yourself. Did you ask for help. Did you keep going when you were not sure how it would turn out.
  • Step 4: Write down at least one thing you have never given yourself credit for. Something you minimized, dismissed, or simply moved past. Tara asks for ten, and settles for one.
  • Step 5: Bring it into the present. Name something you are navigating right now that makes you feel stuck, then write what you already know about yourself from that earlier experience that you may have forgotten.

HatchPath · Evidence & Action Worksheet

The Evidence & Action Worksheet

Confidence isn't something you talk yourself into. It's evidence you collect. Take a few minutes to look back at something difficult you've navigated. This is not about comparing experiences or measuring how hard things were. It's about recognizing what you did, the strengths you used, and the evidence you can carry into what comes next.

1

What happened?

What was the situation? What were you facing? What made it difficult?

2

What did you do?

What decisions did you make? What actions did you take? What helped you navigate it?

3

What strengths did you demonstrate?

Did you show courage, adaptability, determination, resourcefulness, self-advocacy, or something else?

4

What have you never given yourself credit for?

What did you do that you may have minimized, dismissed, or simply moved past?

5

What can you bring forward?

What from that experience could help you with something you're navigating today?

Turn your evidence into action

You don't need the entire plan. Start with one intentional step.

My evidence

One difficult thing I've navigated, and what it demonstrated about me:

My strength

One quality or capability I want to recognize and bring forward:

My next action(s)

1–3 specific things I will do over the next 30 days:

You are not starting from zero. You are starting from experience.

Fill in at least one field and you can email yourself a copy.

The reason it works is a small asymmetry in how memory behaves. Humans are excellent at remembering what happened to us. We are far worse at recognizing what we did in response to what happened to us. We remember the challenge and forget our own contribution to getting through it. Repeat that often enough and every new difficulty arrives looking like the biggest thing that has ever happened to you, as though you have navigated nothing before.

You have done really hard things. You have a history, and you have experience. That is the evidence, and it is yours to take forward.

What Tara Counts as Her Own Evidence

Jordan asked her for one hard thing she got through that she had never given herself credit for. Her answer was recent. After leaving the relationship that had cost her the timeline she planned on, she decided to pursue motherhood on her own and went through IVF from 41 to 43. It did not work. She made the decision to stop.

She could have kept going. Doctors and people around her were telling her to keep going, that her miracle was coming. She decided the process was depleting her physically, emotionally, and financially, and that she was going to choose herself in a very different way. For roughly six months after that decision she gave herself no credit for it at all. She was unkind to herself and fixated on the choices she had made in her thirties. Only in looking back did she see it clearly. Stopping took courage. It was the first time she had ever chosen herself over everyone else's expectations, and that is not surviving, that is strength.

Confidence Is the Receipt

Jordan asked whether confidence can be created before you do the thing. His own answer, after years of trial and error, is that it cannot, but that it transfers. Once you have built it in one area of your life, it becomes closer to a skill you can carry into the rest.

Tara agreed with one caveat. There is no ceiling, and confidence does not automatically cover every room. You can be deeply confident in your career and feel like a beginner in a new relationship. The mechanism stays the same regardless: you start, you sit in the discomfort, and the confidence arrives afterward as the receipt.

"Confidence is the receipt you get for doing hard things." - Tara Resnick

Look at the Step, Not the Staircase

The second half of getting unstuck is scope. Tara's image for it is a staircase. If you stand at the bottom and stare at the top, at the whole new life, the new home, the lawyers, the entirely rebuilt version of your days, you will not take the first step. It is the same failure mode as waiting to feel ready.

Look down instead, and make each step small enough to actually take. The first step might simply be thinking honestly about how you would leave. Not leaving today. Thinking. Opening your own bank account. One conversation. Do that enough times and you are at the top without ever having faced the staircase.

Jordan brought it back to the two things he kept from four years and more than two hundred sessions with his own coach. The first was to lead with a servant's heart. When nerves show up before he speaks or walks into a room, he reminds himself that he is there to deliver value, not to be liked, and the nerves settle. The second was to break goals down using the RPM method so that the first action is always visible.

Do the Exercise Now

Tara's closing ask was deliberately small. Grab something to write with, pick one hard thing you have already come through, and work the five steps. Progress, not perfection. The worksheet above finishes by turning your evidence into one to three actions for the next 30 days. Then keep it somewhere you can find it, because this is not a one time exercise. Every time you feel stuck, every time the sunk cost logic shows up, every time your confidence goes missing, the same five questions apply to any experience at any stage of life.

Two lines from the session are worth carrying into the week. Thoughts are not facts. And problems are not a malfunction. As Jordan put it, the only state with no problems at all is not one any of us is trying to reach. Which means the goal was never a life without hard things. It was a life where you know, with evidence, that you can handle them.

Tara Resnick is a solution-focused coach with HatchPath, working with members on clarity, confidence, and direction through meaningful transitions. If this session described the place you are in, book a free concierge call and we will match you with the right coach for it.

evidence exerciseconfidencegetting unstucksunk cost fallacysolution-focused coachingresiliencesummit
Tara Resnick

About the Author

Tara Resnick

Solution-Focused Coach · Life & Career